A Bullet for the General

A Bullet for the General (Quién sabe?)

Movie · 1966 · 14 people

Damiano Damiani directed the 1966 Italian western A Bullet for the General, originally Quién sabe? ("Who knows?"). It is counted among the first and best-known Zapata Westerns, the spaghetti-western sub-genre set around the Mexican Revolution in which characters confronted with injustice turn into revolutionaries. Gian Maria Volonté, Lou Castel, Klaus Kinski and Martine Beswick star. In France it is known as El Chuncho and in Germany as Töte Amigo.

The story is set in Mexico during the revolutionary fighting; one source gives 1917. El Chuncho (Gian Maria Volonté) leads a gang poised between banditry and guerrilla struggle, and he and his men attack a regular army train. A young American on board, Bill Tate (Lou Castel), helps the raiders during the assault, then joins the gang and earns Chuncho's friendship. Their plan is to sell the captured weapons to General Elías's revolutionaries. But appearances deceive: Tate is in fact a counter-revolutionary hired killer. The relationship changes everything for Chuncho, who learns the hard way that a social revolution matters more than money. Andrea Checchi and Aldo Sambrell are also in the cast.

Franco Solinas and Salvatore Laurani wrote the screenplay, Luis Bacalov composed the music (Ennio Morricone is credited as supervisor) and Bianco Manini produced. It runs about 118 minutes.

DirectorDamiano Damiani

Reactions

You can pick up to 3 reactions.

Cast

Only cast members with a profile on this site are listed.

Aldo Sambrell Aldo Sambrell Film actor · died at 79 Sal Borgese Sal Borgese Actor · 89 years old Gian Maria Volontè Klaus Kinski Martine Beswick Lou Castel Andrea Checchi Carla Gravina José Manuel Martín Valentino Macchi Jaime Fernández Damiano Damiani Rufino Inglés Spartaco Conversi

Through different eyes

Action & Thriller Fan Puts pace, tension and set pieces first; little patience for slow drama.

Train raid, gun-running, a revolutionary general: on paper it's the full action package. But the film builds its real tension less from shootouts than from the trust between two men. Knowing who Tate really is makes every scene they share uneasy. Anyone expecting wall-to-wall duels may feel the pace drifts into talk at times; this is a political thriller first, and the action serves it.

Cinephile Looks at script, editing and directing choices; keeps a distance from formula films.

Quién sabe? is one of the early films that turned spaghetti-western conventions into a political argument, and its strength lies in how the script is built. Franco Solinas and Salvatore Laurani tell the story of revolution not through speeches but through a deception planted inside a friendship, so the ideology feels like a natural outgrowth of the relationship. Damiani keeps the genre's visual language while putting the weight on Chuncho's transformation. The weakness sits in the same place: the clarity of the thesis sometimes reduces the supporting characters to symbols, and the message comes close to overtaking the drama. Still, for anyone who wants to see why the Zapata Western is taken seriously, it is an essential reference.

History & Society Lens Asks about the period, the social background and what the work reflects.

The film is about the Mexican Revolution, but in my view it also reflects how the idea of revolution was being argued over in 1960s European cinema. Its most interesting question is the thin line between banditry and guerrilla struggle: where does someone who sells captured guns for cash stand in a revolution? A young American stepping into the conflict from outside is also a pointed comment on the role of foreign interests in local struggles. Don't expect a meticulous history lesson; Mexico is more of a backdrop here, and the real subject is the choice between self-interest and principle, and how class consciousness awakens.

These are not reader reviews: they are short editorial takes written from different viewer perspectives with AI assistance. Reader reviews are below.

Reviews (0)

Log in Log in to write a review.

Comments