The Karadede Affair (Karadedeler Olayı)

The Karadede Affair (Karadedeler Olayı) (translated)

Movie · 2011 · 7 people

The Turkish horror-thriller Karadedeler Olayı came out on September 16, 2011. Erkan Bağbakan directed it from a screenplay by Erdoğan Bağbakan, and the 78-minute film uses the found-footage format, as if assembled from raw recordings recovered later. That vein runs from Ruggero Deodato's Cannibal Holocaust through The Blair Witch Project, Paranormal Activity and [Rec], and it is one of Turkey's takes on the trend.

It presents itself as a document rather than fiction: the producers argued that the events were pieced together from amateur videos shot in 1989, and the marketing leaned heavily on that claim. The story follows a young journalist, H.B., drawn by odd village stories in the newspapers of January 1989. Frightened locals speak of creatures walking at night and of jinn. After weeks without seeing anything unusual, he leaves his camera with a local youth and goes back to Istanbul. Three days later the gendarmes detain him: seven people, the youth among them, have been torn apart. Released after his statement, he vanishes, his belongings left in the forest. Through all of it the cameras keep rolling.

DirectorErkan Bağbakan
The Karadede Affair (Karadedeler Olayı) The Karadede Affair (Karadedeler Olayı)

Reactions

You can pick up to 3 reactions.

Cast

Saim Karakale Saim Karakale Actor · 39 years old Murat Han Murat Han Actor · 51 years old Berk Balcı İpek Ayaz Kortunç Oğuzhan Koca Kadir Yüksel Ada Hackett

Through different eyes

Cinephile Looks at script, editing and directing choices; keeps a distance from formula films.

Found footage is not a cheap shortcut but a contract that demands discipline: why is the camera running, who is holding it, who assembled the tapes? Karadedeler Olayı lines up the genre's conventions without building a convincing answer to any of those questions. The Blair Witch Project drew its power from the gap left by what we never see; here that gap never becomes dramatic tension and stays mere waiting. Marketing the film as a document reads less like formal daring than like a publicity move. It has curiosity value as one of Turkey's entries in the genre, but it adds nothing tangible to the form.

Action & Thriller Fan Puts pace, tension and set pieces first; little patience for slow drama.

A village, creatures roaming at night, talk of jinn and cameras that never stop rolling: on paper it is a ready-made recipe for tension. The trouble is that this kind of film works by stacking fear bit by bit, and the stacking here is far too thin. The sense that something is about to happen does not stay alive. Found-footage fans may try it out of curiosity; anyone after a tight horror film will find it weak.

History & Society Lens Asks about the period, the social background and what the work reflects.

What is most interesting about the film is its choice of the 1989 provinces as a setting for horror. Strange village stories in the newspapers, tales of jinn and night creatures, a young journalist arriving from Istanbul: that triangle offers material for thinking about the mistrust between city and village and how rumor can take hold of a community. Yet the film leans on its claim to present legend as fact rather than opening that material to any social reading. Even so, it is a case worth discussing for anyone curious about the link between the press, rumor and fear in late-1980s Turkey.

These are not reader reviews: they are short editorial takes written from different viewer perspectives with AI assistance. Reader reviews are below.

Reviews (0)

Log in Log in to write a review.

Comments